Here’s a bold statement: The All Blacks’ victory over Ireland wasn’t just a win—it was a turning point that kept their Grand Slam dreams alive. But here’s where it gets controversial: Was Ireland truly outplayed, or did they simply let the match slip away in the final quarter? This question has sparked heated debates among fans and pundits alike. Let’s dive into the analysis and uncover the key takeaways that most people might have missed.
Scotty Stevenson and Pat McKendry argue that resting Cam Roigard this week would be a risky move, given his pivotal role as a playmaker for the All Blacks. And this is the part most people miss: Roigard’s apparent lack of running in the first 50 minutes against Ireland wasn’t a weakness—it was a masterclass in awareness, showcasing his ability to read the opposition’s defense. When the opportunity arose later, he capitalized brilliantly, proving his value to the team.
The match against Ireland was far from perfect. A disjointed first half, disrupted by the early loss of two Barrett brothers, highlighted the team’s struggles to sync their energy with execution. Yet, the All Blacks’ resilience shone through, particularly in the final quarter, where they dominated with late scrum power and disciplined play. Here’s a thought-provoking question: Did the officiating—including a controversial red card for Tadhg Beirne—take some of the shine off the occasion, or was it simply part of the game’s unpredictability?
The extended squad’s contributions were a highlight, with players like Josh Lord, Wallace Sititi, Quinn Tupaea, and Leicester Fainga’anuku stepping up impressively. Tupaea, in particular, has been a revelation, earning his spot as a midfield stalwart. But here’s a counterpoint: Should Fainga’anuku be considered the long-term center when Jordie Barrett returns, or has Tupaea already cemented his place?
Looking ahead to Scotland, the All Blacks face a formidable challenge. Under Gregor Townsend, Scotland will be at full strength and eager to prove themselves at Murrayfield. Here’s where it gets even more intriguing: With a tough match against England looming the following week, can the selectors afford to make changes, or will they stick with a backline that’s finally showing cohesion?
Tactically, the All Blacks are likely to rely on their scrum dominance and a short kicking game to exploit spaces, particularly in Finn Russell’s channel. A controversial interpretation: While Russell is a standout player for Scotland, the All Blacks’ depth and dynamism may prove too much for the home side to handle.
In the end, the Test will likely be won by the team that starts strong and maintains momentum. The All Blacks’ bench power and pace should give them the edge, with a predicted victory margin of 12-20 points. But what do you think? Is Scotland being underestimated, or will the All Blacks’ depth and strategy secure another step toward Grand Slam glory? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments!
